What Makes a Good Orchestra Experience?

I've played in a fair number of groups over the years.  Some were really awesome and motivated me to practice, increased my love of my instrument and music, and taught me a lot.  Others were not so awesome and were more frustrating, making me want to walk away and never return.  What were the differences?

A lot has to do with how the orchestra is run.  Sure, it can be fun to be social and chat a lot, but I was trained by a couple of professional musicians who expected their students to act professionally too.  So to me, a rehearsal should get down to business and rehearse.  There's still time before and after rehearsal, and during any breaks, for socializing.

The conductor makes a big difference.  A conductor who can constructively critique the group's playing, and pinpoint what needs to be corrected, is essential.  Anything else is just a waste of time, because why else are you rehearsing?

What is the conductor's attitude?  Does he or she show up early to answer questions and start rehearsal on time, or do they waltz in 15 minutes late and expect you to wait for them?  Respect works both ways, so the conductor should respect the musicians and what they are contributing.

A lot has to do with the musicians themselves.  Not just their playing ability, although it can be very pleasurable to be able to sight read through a major symphony with a modicum of competence.  But what are the attitudes of the players?  Do they respect each other and their conductor?  Do they show up on time, with their parts prepared?  Did they come to socialize, to have fun, to learn, to make music?  Sure, this is all a part of orchestra, but finding a group that is in line with your own attitude can make or break the difference.

Finally, assess the overall feel of the group.  Is this somewhere your contributions are valued?  Do you go home feeling energized or drained?  If one group leaves you feeling frustrated, don't despair!  There are lots of community, student, and professional groups out there, so go try a different one.

A good place to start your search is on the Community Band and Orchestra Links page.  You can also ask your private teacher, your school teacher, or even music stores about groups in your area.

Happy Playing!